meed-logo

line1 line2 line3
SIGN IN / REGISTER

Risks remain for GCC railway project

28 August 2023

 

Register for MEED's guest programme 

When the GCC secretariat agreed to restart the GCC Railway Project in 2021, it set the tone for one of the region’s most ambitious transnational projects.

The endeavour aims to connect the six Gulf nations with a sprawling railway network that will be a game-changer for the region’s infrastructure. The potential to boost trade, connectivity and regional economic development is enormous. 

But risks and challenges also lie ahead, including cost overruns and technical risks related to the project design, engineering and complexity that must be assessed, managed and monitored to ensure the project’s successful delivery.

Political risks

Political factors play a significant role in the development and operation of the GCC railway. Given that the network will traverse multiple geographies, one of its biggest tests is manoeuvring through the regional political landscape.

First and foremost among political considerations is the level of cooperation and diplomatic relations between the member states. The railway’s seamless operation relies on harmonised regulations, standard operating procedures and open communication between nations, as well as geopolitical stability. 

In this respect, the Al-Alu agreement of 2021 is key, as it laid the strong foundations for a more robust mechanism to ensure better cooperation between the GCC countries.

“The Qatar blockade was a big challenge to manage and the GCC countries have seen the consequences of the situation,” Alexandre Busson (right), director of rail, Hill International, tells MEED.

“They realised that there was no benefit in it for the region. So the Al-Ula declaration is really important.”

But while the agreement mitigates the political risk related to the GCC railway project to some extent, the potential for geopolitical tensions or disputes between the involved states remains and could impede the project’s progress by delaying decisions, complicating negotiations and disrupting work.

The GCC countries' wide-ranging economic interests and priorities could also impact their commitment to the railway project. Member states will need to consider their existing investments in other forms of transportation infrastructure, such as ports and highways. Balancing these interests requires careful negotiations and alignment of economic visions.

PPP contracts are more complex to negotiate and manage. But it [will be] very interesting to see how it goes because a successful PPP project could lead to the opening up of the market
Alexandre Busson, Hill International

Financial risks

The enormity of the GCC Railway Project becomes apparent when considering the huge costs involved. Laying tracks spanning six countries and crossing diverse terrains and urban areas, building stations, installing signalling systems and ensuring the safety of the network demands billions of dollars’ worth of investment.

With the financial stability of GCC nations closely tied to the global oil market, fluctuations in oil prices could significantly impact the ability and political will of governments to allocate funds to the GCC Railway Project.

“When GCC countries budget for infrastructure projects, they are very conservative with regards to the oil price in their budget,” says Busson. “And in terms of projects financing, they realise [the need] to diversify the economy and not be too dependent on oil prices.” 

Nevertheless, economic diversification plans mean each GCC nation faces its own set of budget constraints and priorities. Regional governments must juggle allocating limited funds to sectors such as healthcare, education, defence and infrastructure. The GCC Railway Project’s financial demands could strain these budgets, potentially diverting resources away from critical sectors.

To bridge the financial gap, governments are likely to explore a combination of public financing and private investment. Public-private partnerships (PPPs) have attracted interest from large-scale infrastructure projects in the region and the GCC railway will be no different. Luring private investors, however, requires a stable and attractive investment environment, coupled with clear revenue-generation models and risk-sharing agreements.

“The PPP model is quite new in the GCC. Even more so in transport,” says Busson. “Those kinds of contracts are more complex to negotiate and manage. But it [will be] very interesting to see how it goes because a successful PPP project could lead to the opening up of the market.”

You need to look at the consortium members and say, do we have the right balance within that particular consortium to be able to manage this project
Christopher Harding, Hill International

Technical risks

The technical risks of rail systems running across international borders are well documented. Examples include the Tan-Zam railway between Tanzania and Zambia and the rail link connecting Spain and France, where the adoption of different gauges meant construction was fraught with technical difficulties when joining the networks to each other.

“Inaccurate or complex specifications sometimes lead to extra efforts [needing] to be put into the interface management and getting interface agreements between the contractors,” explains Christopher Harding (right), a senior project management professional currently working on the Cairo Metro project for US-based consultant Hill International.

“That leads to claims from contractors and hence may lead to cost overruns.”

The complexity of the GCC Railway Project raises the stakes when it comes to technical risks. Meticulous planning and implementation will be required to ensure seamless connectivity across deserts, mountains and coastal areas, while the need for bridges, tunnels and viaducts to overcome geographical obstacles demands robust engineering solutions. 

Addressing these engineering risks requires a comprehensive understanding of the local environment, as well as innovative and consistent engineering techniques.

“There needs to be a common policy on the control systems for each country and how they talk to each other,” says Harding.

The involvement of multiple contractors will bring contractor-related risks too. Coordination between these entities will be key, as delays in one segment could cascade through the entire network, causing misalignments and operational bottlenecks.

“You need to look at the consortium members and say, do we have the right balance within that particular consortium to be able to manage this project,” says Harding.

Another significant challenge will be maintaining uniform quality standards across the contractors working on the GCC Railway Project to prevent differing construction techniques, materials and safety practices from potentially compromising the railway’s overall integrity and efficiency. 

“The rules around aspects like recruitment localisation, In-country Value (ICV), In-Kingdom Total Value Add (IKTVA) and regional headquarters requirement could be a challenge for new companies,” adds Busson.

The establishment of the GCC Railway Authority to oversee the overall implementation of the project will go some way towards resolving the technical issues outlined here. The authority is tasked with ensuring common standards and specifications, and supervising the railway’s interoperability and regional integration.

For the project to succeed, the authority must develop robust risk management strategies, effective communication channels among contractors, stringent quality control measures and transparent procurement processes.

https://image.digitalinsightresearch.in/uploads/NewsArticle/11099328/main.jpg
Yasir Iqbal

Register for MEED's guest program now to access this article.

Click here to register
Exclusive from Meed
Related Articles
  • Egypt approves Russian nuclear financing amendment

    4 February 2025

    The Egyptian House of Representatives has approved a report, previously ratified by the North African nation's Energy & Environment Committee, that amends the government financing agreement between Egypt and Russia over the El-Dabaa nuclear power plant in Matrouh.

    The agreement secures a government export loan from Moscow to support the construction of Egypt’s first nuclear power plant.

    According to a local media report, the decree was reviewed by a joint committee that included members of the Energy & Environment Committee, as well as representatives from the Planning & Budget, Economic Affairs and Foreign Relations Committees.

    The amendments to the financing agreement aim to "align the loan's terms with the project's implementation schedule".

    The report did not disclose the nature of the financing amendment that has been approved.

    Financing details

    Egypt and Russia signed the initial inter-governmental agreement for the North African state’s first nuclear facility in November 2015.

    MEED understands that the existing agreement entails an 85:15 project financing split between Russia and Egypt.

    The project is expected to cost between $25bn and $30bn.

    According to industry sources, the funds Russia is providing are payable over 22 years in 43 semi-annual installments, with the first installment due on 15 October 2029.

    MEED understands Egypt can repay the loan in US dollars or Egyptian pounds, whichever suits the Russian party better, and that "a very affordable" 3% annual interest rate applies.  

    The power plant will be equipped with four Russian-designed, 1,200MW VVER reactor units.

    When complete, the El-Dabaa nuclear power plant is expected to generate more than 10% of electricity production in Egypt.

    The plant’s first reactor is scheduled to be operational in 2026.

    Russia’s State Atomic Energy Corporation (Rosatom), the project’s main contractor, announced that it started the production of electrical components in Saint Petersburg for a reactor vessel for the plant in June 2022.

    https://image.digitalinsightresearch.in/uploads/NewsArticle/13360633/main.jpg
    Jennifer Aguinaldo
  • Abu Dhabi plans estimated 10GW data centre capacity

    4 February 2025

     

    Abu Dhabi is planning to invest in data centres with a total combined IT load capacity equivalent to an estimated 10,000MW.

    According to industry sources, the locations that are being considered are in Abu Dhabi's Dhafra region, previously known as the Western or Al-Gharbia region, including one close to the Barakah nuclear power plant.

    In addition to the nuclear power plant, which has a total nameplate capacity of 5,600MW, Abu Dhabi's second utility-scale solar photovoltaic (PV) independent power project is located in Al-Dhafra.

    Abu Dhabi National Energy Company (Taqa) is also procuring an open-cycle gas turbine (OCGT) plant to be located in the region. The Al-Dhafra OCGT plant is being tendered on a fast-track basis and is expected to have an installed capacity of 1,000MW-1,100MW.

    State utility offtaker Emirates Water & Electricity Company and Abu Dhabi Future Energy Company (Masdar) have yet to disclose the locations for the gigawatt-scale solar PV and battery energy storage system (bess) plants that they are planning to develop as part of the UAE's national net-zero target and artificial intelligence (AI) strategy.

    The project comprises 5,200MW solar PV and 19 gigawatt-hour (GWh) bess plants that are expected to supply 1,000MW of round-the-clock renewable power.     

    Experts have advised colocating data hyperscale centres, particularly those designed for training AI large-language models that have an electrical output similar to small towns or cities, with power generation sources.

    This helps bypass complex and time-consuming grid connection upgrades and approvals processes and minimises energy waste.

    Data centres designed for inferencing AI models, however, need to be built close to load centres or cities for improved latency.  

    "Lots of data centre project activity in Abu Dhabi at the moment," said a senior technical consultant, who also cautions there might be duplications in terms of these "concept projects".

    Karen Young, senior research scholar at Columbia University’s Centre on Global Energy Policy, also observes the uptick in project activity, as well as in policies directly related to AI and data centres in the UAE.

    "It's a lot to keep track of, and the new doubt that we may be able to do supercomputing with less power and investment, and cheaper inputs, makes the race for energy infrastructure and data centre placement slightly more risky," she tells MEED.

    Related read: DeepSeek complicates regional data centre choices

    "All the same, the UAE has made a strategic decision to lead the space and it changes the global landscape of where this advances and which countries have advantages to control it."

    GCC data centre market

    Over $10.6bn-worth of data centres, some catering to hyperscalers such as Amazon Web Services and Microsoft, are planned to be developed and built in the GCC states, according to the latest available data from regional projects tracker MEED Projects.

    This is a conservative estimate, given potential investments such as the $5bn planned between US asset investment firm KKR and the UAE-based Gulf Data Hub.

    It also excludes spending by government entities to develop AI capabilities in defence, security, healthcare and energy.

    https://image.digitalinsightresearch.in/uploads/NewsArticle/13360347/main1606.jpg
    Jennifer Aguinaldo
  • UAE data centre policy highlights AI-energy nexus

    4 February 2025

    Commentary
    Jennifer Aguinaldo
    Energy & technology editor

    The UAE National Team for Reviewing the Impact of Data Centres on the Energy Sector held its inaugural meeting on 3 February.

    The UAE Ministry of Energy & Infrastructure (MoEI)-attached entity was formed to assess the impact of data centres on the domestic energy sector and to work on developing a federal policy aimed at regulating the operation of local data centres.

    Sharif Al-Olama, undersecretary for energy and petroleum affairs at the MoEI, said the formation of the national team is part of the state's strategic efforts towards digital transformation and enhancing sustainability in the energy sector.

    This development follows significant initiatives aligned with the UAE's national artificial intelligence (AI) strategy.

    For instance, Emirates Water & Electricity Company and Abu Dhabi Future Energy Company (Masdar) announced the $6bn "gigawatt-scale" solar photovoltaic (PV) and battery energy storage system (bess) project in Abu Dhabi in mid-January.

    The project, comprising 5,200MW of solar PV and a 19 gigawatt-hour (GWh) bess plant, is expected to provide 1,000MW of round-the-clock, baseload renewable power.

    The UAE leadership has said this project will help advance AI and other emerging technologies while contributing to its 2050 net-zero target.

    Advanced AI models require the construction of hyperscale – large-capacity and low-latency – data centres, which consume large amounts of electricity, impacting consumption, supply, planning and carbon emissions.

    A federal policy could help streamline the entire ecosystem and mobilise plans to ensure no single point of failure once all the planned data centres start operating.

    This move comes a few months after the UAE cabinet approved the state's international AI policy in October, which focuses on advancement, cooperation, community, ethics, sustainability and security.

    In addition to helping shape future standards and guidelines in AI diffusion, the UAE foreign AI policy advocates "transparency and built-in checkpoints within AI tools, enabling governments to enforce ethical standards and implement accountability measures".

    Investors and data centre operators will be watching these evolving policies with great interest to ensure compliance, and to see what impact they might have on capital and operating expenses, if any. 

     

    https://image.digitalinsightresearch.in/uploads/NewsArticle/13357411/main1654.jpg
    Jennifer Aguinaldo
  • UAE government eyes federal data centre policy

    3 February 2025

    A UAE national team has been formed to assess the impact of data centres on the domestic energy sector and work on developing a federal policy aimed at regulating the operation of local data centres.

    The UAE Ministry of Energy and Infrastructure (MoEI)-attached national team held its first meeting in Dubai, Emirates News Agency (Wam) reported on 3 February.

    At its inaugural meeting, the National Team for Reviewing the Impact of Data Centres on the Energy Sector, explored the development of data centres in the UAE and their influence on the local energy sector.

    The report added: "It also highlighted the challenges facing data centres, ways to make them more sustainable, and the importance of adopting global best practices to ensure efficient operation of these centres".

    Related read: AI chip restriction may slow down GCC data centre boom

    The team is tasked with a"nalysing and reviewing the impact of data centres on energy demand, evaluating the local market and projected economic return for this key sector, identifying all data centres in the country and classifying them according to specific standards".

    The team will also conduct a geographical study of the distribution of current and future data centres to ensure optimal infrastructure distribution, perform benchmark comparisons to review global best practices in data centres, and work on developing a federal policy aimed at regulating the operation of local data centres.

    Sharif Al-Olama, Undersecretary for Energy and Petroleum Affairs at MoEI and Saif Ghubash, assistant undersecretary for Petroleum, Gas, and Mineral Resources at MoEI participated in the meeting, along with key team members from various ministries including the Ministry of Industry and Advanced Technology, the Ministry of Climate Change and Environment, the Telecommunications and Digital Government Regulatory Authority, the Artificial Intelligence, Digital Economy, and Remote Work Applications Office, among others.

    Related read: AI underpins 5GW Abu Dhabi solar project

    During the meeting, Al-Olama underscored the importance of collaboration among member entities to achieve the team's objectives, including adopting innovative solutions to reduce energy consumption and enhancing the operational efficiency of data centres.

    He added that the formation of the National Team is part of the country's strategic directions towards digital transformation and enhancing sustainability in the energy sector.

    He emphasised the need to develop innovative solutions to ensure a balance between the demands of technological development and the sustainability of energy resources in alignment with national goals.

    Al-Olama also highlighted the importance of establishing a comprehensive framework that includes analytical studies and clear recommendations based on accurate data, which will contribute to making strategic decisions capable of achieving the country's energy goals, particularly in clean and renewable energy.

    Close to $2bn worth of data centre projects are under construction in the UAE, according to latest available MEED Projects data.

    Over $10.6bn-worth of data centres, some catering to hyperscalers such as Amazon Web Services and Microsoft, are planned to be developed and built across the GCC states.

    Photo credit: Wam

    https://image.digitalinsightresearch.in/uploads/NewsArticle/13357025/main.jpg
    Jennifer Aguinaldo
  • Saudi Arabia invites bids for 2GW battery IPPs

    3 February 2025

     

    Register for MEED's 14-day trial access 

    Principal buyer Saudi Power Procurement Company (SPPC) has invited prequalified firms to bid for the contracts to develop the first phase of independent battery energy storage system (bess) projects in Saudi Arabia.

    The group one bess – also called independent storage provider (ISP) – projects will be developed using a build, own and operate (BOO) model.

    They comprise the following schemes with a total combined capacity of 2,000MW, which equates to about four hours or 8,000 megawatt-hours (MWh) of storage:

    • Al-Muwyah bess ISP: 500MW (Mecca)
    • Haden bess ISP: 500MW (Mecca) 
    • Al-Khushaybi bess ISP: 500MW (Qassim)
    • Al-Kahafa bess ISP: 500MW (Hail)

    MEED understands a bidders conference is set for 17 February, to be followed by site visits.

    The principal buyer expects to receive the letters of intention by April and the proposals by 2 June.

    The following 21 companies have been prequalified to bid for the contracts as managing or technical partners:

    • Abu Dhabi Future Energy Company (Masdar, UAE)
    • Abu Dhabi National Energy Company (Taqa, UAE)
    • Acwa Power (local)
    • Akaysha Energy (Australia)
    • China Energy Overseas Investment Company (CEECOIC, China)
    • China Power Engineering Consulting Group International Engineering (China)
    • China Southern Power Grid International (HK) Company (CSGIHK)
    • Cox Energy (Spain)
    • EDF (France)
    • Envision Energy (China)
    • FRV-X Renewable (Spain)
    • International Power (Engie, France)
    • Jera Nex (Japan) 
    • Jinko Power (Hong Kong) 
    • Korea Electric Power Corporation (Kepco, South Korea)
    • Marubeni Corporation (Japan)
    • Pro-Power Investment (China)
    • Samsung C&T Corporation (South Korea)
    • SPIC Huanghe Hydropower Development Company (China)
    • TotalEnergies Renewables (France)
    • X-Elio Energy 

    The following firms may bid as technical partners:

    • Al-Gihaz Holding Company (local)
    • Al-Jomaih Energy & Water Company (local)
    • Alfanar Company (local)
    • FAS Energy (local)
    • GCL Intelligent Energy (Suzhou, China)
    • Gulf Energy Development Public Company (Thailand)
    • Nesma Renewable Energy (local)
    • Posco International Corporation (South Korea)
    • Power Construction Corporation of China (PowerChina) 
    • Saudi Electricity Company (local)
    • Shell Overseas Investment (UK)
    • Sumitomo Corporation (Japan)

    The successful bidders will hold 100% equity in the special purpose vehicle (SPV) set up to develop and operate each ISP.

    The SPVs will enter into a 15-year storage services agreement with the principal buyer.

    According to SPPC, the energy storage programme will enable the kingdom’s energy mix to contain 50% renewable energy by 2030 while enhancing the reliability and resilience of the electric power system.

    MEED reported in May last year that SPPC was several months away from seeking developers’ interest in the contract to develop and operate the 2,000MW first phase of an energy storage system catering to the kingdom’s electricity grid.

    It is understood that SPPC plans to procure up to 10,000MW of bess capacity by 2030.

    The planned bess facilities are to be built near demand centres. As more renewable energy enters the electricity production mix, they will boost the grid’s spinning reserves.

    Bess comprises rechargeable batteries that can store and discharge energy from various sources when needed. It is one of the key solutions being considered to address the intermittency of renewable energy sources.

    US/India-based Synergy Consulting is advising SPPC on the energy storage capacity procurement programme.

    https://image.digitalinsightresearch.in/uploads/NewsArticle/13356657/main4004.jpg
    Jennifer Aguinaldo