meed-logo

line1 line2 line3
SIGN IN / REGISTER

Risks remain for GCC railway project

28 August 2023

 

Register for MEED's guest programme 

When the GCC secretariat agreed to restart the GCC Railway Project in 2021, it set the tone for one of the region’s most ambitious transnational projects.

The endeavour aims to connect the six Gulf nations with a sprawling railway network that will be a game-changer for the region’s infrastructure. The potential to boost trade, connectivity and regional economic development is enormous. 

But risks and challenges also lie ahead, including cost overruns and technical risks related to the project design, engineering and complexity that must be assessed, managed and monitored to ensure the project’s successful delivery.

Political risks

Political factors play a significant role in the development and operation of the GCC railway. Given that the network will traverse multiple geographies, one of its biggest tests is manoeuvring through the regional political landscape.

First and foremost among political considerations is the level of cooperation and diplomatic relations between the member states. The railway’s seamless operation relies on harmonised regulations, standard operating procedures and open communication between nations, as well as geopolitical stability. 

In this respect, the Al-Alu agreement of 2021 is key, as it laid the strong foundations for a more robust mechanism to ensure better cooperation between the GCC countries.

“The Qatar blockade was a big challenge to manage and the GCC countries have seen the consequences of the situation,” Alexandre Busson (right), director of rail, Hill International, tells MEED.

“They realised that there was no benefit in it for the region. So the Al-Ula declaration is really important.”

But while the agreement mitigates the political risk related to the GCC railway project to some extent, the potential for geopolitical tensions or disputes between the involved states remains and could impede the project’s progress by delaying decisions, complicating negotiations and disrupting work.

The GCC countries' wide-ranging economic interests and priorities could also impact their commitment to the railway project. Member states will need to consider their existing investments in other forms of transportation infrastructure, such as ports and highways. Balancing these interests requires careful negotiations and alignment of economic visions.

PPP contracts are more complex to negotiate and manage. But it [will be] very interesting to see how it goes because a successful PPP project could lead to the opening up of the market
Alexandre Busson, Hill International

Financial risks

The enormity of the GCC Railway Project becomes apparent when considering the huge costs involved. Laying tracks spanning six countries and crossing diverse terrains and urban areas, building stations, installing signalling systems and ensuring the safety of the network demands billions of dollars’ worth of investment.

With the financial stability of GCC nations closely tied to the global oil market, fluctuations in oil prices could significantly impact the ability and political will of governments to allocate funds to the GCC Railway Project.

“When GCC countries budget for infrastructure projects, they are very conservative with regards to the oil price in their budget,” says Busson. “And in terms of projects financing, they realise [the need] to diversify the economy and not be too dependent on oil prices.” 

Nevertheless, economic diversification plans mean each GCC nation faces its own set of budget constraints and priorities. Regional governments must juggle allocating limited funds to sectors such as healthcare, education, defence and infrastructure. The GCC Railway Project’s financial demands could strain these budgets, potentially diverting resources away from critical sectors.

To bridge the financial gap, governments are likely to explore a combination of public financing and private investment. Public-private partnerships (PPPs) have attracted interest from large-scale infrastructure projects in the region and the GCC railway will be no different. Luring private investors, however, requires a stable and attractive investment environment, coupled with clear revenue-generation models and risk-sharing agreements.

“The PPP model is quite new in the GCC. Even more so in transport,” says Busson. “Those kinds of contracts are more complex to negotiate and manage. But it [will be] very interesting to see how it goes because a successful PPP project could lead to the opening up of the market.”

You need to look at the consortium members and say, do we have the right balance within that particular consortium to be able to manage this project
Christopher Harding, Hill International

Technical risks

The technical risks of rail systems running across international borders are well documented. Examples include the Tan-Zam railway between Tanzania and Zambia and the rail link connecting Spain and France, where the adoption of different gauges meant construction was fraught with technical difficulties when joining the networks to each other.

“Inaccurate or complex specifications sometimes lead to extra efforts [needing] to be put into the interface management and getting interface agreements between the contractors,” explains Christopher Harding (right), a senior project management professional currently working on the Cairo Metro project for US-based consultant Hill International.

“That leads to claims from contractors and hence may lead to cost overruns.”

The complexity of the GCC Railway Project raises the stakes when it comes to technical risks. Meticulous planning and implementation will be required to ensure seamless connectivity across deserts, mountains and coastal areas, while the need for bridges, tunnels and viaducts to overcome geographical obstacles demands robust engineering solutions. 

Addressing these engineering risks requires a comprehensive understanding of the local environment, as well as innovative and consistent engineering techniques.

“There needs to be a common policy on the control systems for each country and how they talk to each other,” says Harding.

The involvement of multiple contractors will bring contractor-related risks too. Coordination between these entities will be key, as delays in one segment could cascade through the entire network, causing misalignments and operational bottlenecks.

“You need to look at the consortium members and say, do we have the right balance within that particular consortium to be able to manage this project,” says Harding.

Another significant challenge will be maintaining uniform quality standards across the contractors working on the GCC Railway Project to prevent differing construction techniques, materials and safety practices from potentially compromising the railway’s overall integrity and efficiency. 

“The rules around aspects like recruitment localisation, In-country Value (ICV), In-Kingdom Total Value Add (IKTVA) and regional headquarters requirement could be a challenge for new companies,” adds Busson.

The establishment of the GCC Railway Authority to oversee the overall implementation of the project will go some way towards resolving the technical issues outlined here. The authority is tasked with ensuring common standards and specifications, and supervising the railway’s interoperability and regional integration.

For the project to succeed, the authority must develop robust risk management strategies, effective communication channels among contractors, stringent quality control measures and transparent procurement processes.

https://image.digitalinsightresearch.in/uploads/NewsArticle/11099328/main.jpg
Yasir Iqbal

Register for MEED's guest program now to access this article.

Click here to register
Exclusive from Meed
Related Articles
  • Chinese and Saudi partners set up Hithium Manat

    17 October 2024

    Register for MEED's 14-day trial access 

    Chinese energy storage solutions firm Hithium Energy Storage Technology Company (Hithium) and the local Nabilah AlTunisi have formed a joint venture that will manufacture battery energy storage systems (bess) in Saudi Arabia.

    The joint venture is called Hithium Manat. The planned manufacturing facility has an annual production capacity target of 5 gigawatt-hours (GWh), according to an official statement.

    Hithium launched energy storage solutions designed for the region's harsh environment during a solar and storage conference held in Riyadh.

    According to Hithium, "These systems feature advanced sandstorm protection and robust high and low-temperature designs, supporting ultra-long discharge cycles of 12+ hours."

    It added that the new product line is "customised to meet the unique demands of the Middle East and Africa region".

    Nabilah AlTunisi is the founder and owner of Hithium Manat's local partner.

    "This strategic alliance will not only provide access to world-class energy storage technology but also generate local employment opportunities, stimulate technological innovation and actively contribute to realising the kingdom's Vision 2030 objectives," AlTunisi said.

    Battery energy storage market

    In August, National Grid Saudi Arabia, a subsidiary of state utility Saudi Electricity Company, awarded the engineering, procurement and construction (EPC) contracts for three energy storage systems to Riyadh-based investment group Algihaz Holding. The estimated $800m projects are located in Najran, Madaya and Khamis Mushait.

    National Grid also recently tendered contracts for the construction of five battery energy storage systems with a total combined capacity of 2,500MW across the kingdom.

    The planned facilities, each with a capacity of 500MW or roughly 2,000 megawatt-hours, are located in or within proximity of the following key cities and load centres:

    • Riyadh
    • Qaisumah
    • Dawadmi
    • Al-Jouf
    • Rabigh

    Every utility in the region is procuring or planning to procure bess capacity in light of growing intermittent renewable power in their grids. 

    The overall capacity of deployed bess globally is expected to reach 127GW by 2027, up from an estimated cumulative deployment of 36.7GW at the end of 2023, a GlobalData report issued in June said.

    The report cited Chinese companies BYD and CATL and South Korean companies LG Energy Solutions and Samsung SDI among the top battery technology providers globally.

    Related read: Battery storage gains foothold

    https://image.digitalinsightresearch.in/uploads/NewsArticle/12742375/main.jpg
    Jennifer Aguinaldo
  • Kahramaa invites Ras Laffan substation bids

    17 October 2024

    Qatar state utility General Electricity & Water Corporation (Kahramaa) has tendered a contract to upgrade the Ras Laffan C substation.

    The scope of work covers the upgrade of existing 220-kilovolt (kV) and 400kV substations and the addition of 220kV gas-insulated switchgear bays and an 800-megavolt amps transformer.

    Kahramaa issued the tender on 15 October and expects to receive bids by 28 November.

    The project bid bond is valued at QR1.5m ($410,000).

    Separately, Kahramaa invited firms to submit their proposals for a contract to supply and install power transmission and distribution equipment, including providing and connecting substation main earth and equipment earthing, commissioning fitted substations and pre-commissioning protection testing for 11kV switchgear panels.

    Kahramaa expects to receive bids for this contract, with a bid bond of QR3m, by 14 November.

    Kahramaa is expanding its power generation capacity. Negotiations are under way with the sole bidder led by Japan's Sumitomo Corporation for a contract to develop and operate Qatar’s Facility E independent water and power producer (IWPP) project.

    The Facility E IWPP scheme will have a power generation capacity of 2,300MW and a water desalination capacity of 100 million imperial gallons a day.

    Earlier this month, Qatar Electricity & Water Company announced plans to develop a 500MW peak power unit in Qatar's Ras Abu Fontas area.

    Construction is also under way for two solar farms with a total combined capacity of 875MW in Mesaieed and Ras Laffan.

    https://image.digitalinsightresearch.in/uploads/NewsArticle/12742343/main.jpg
    Jennifer Aguinaldo
  • Neom starts Tabuk highway prequalifications

    17 October 2024

     

    Saudi Arabian gigaproject developer Neom expects firms to submit their prequalification applications for a project to build a mountain road near Tabuk later this month.

    The 11.5-kilometre (km) Tabuk mountain road project comprises a 4km tunnel and 7.5km dualisation of an existing road, according to an industry source.

    Neom expects to receive statements of qualifications from interested engineering, procurement and construction contractors by 29 October.

    The tender proceedings for Neom's transport infrastructure projects are gathering momentum.

    Neom received expressions of interest for a contract to build a coastal highway and infrastructure project catering to the Magna development on the Gulf of Aqaba on 15 October.

    The project, called Magna Infrastructure Packages, is split into three. Package one is 13km, package two is 42km and package three is 41km. The packages cater to the development’s north, central and south areas.

    The design-and-build project covers utilities for water, power, mobility, sewer, buildings and highways, in addition to the coastal highway. The project is expected to be completed by 2027.

    https://image.digitalinsightresearch.in/uploads/NewsArticle/12738632/main.gif
    Jennifer Aguinaldo
  • Adnoc completes Fertiglobe stake acquisition

    16 October 2024

    Register for MEED's 14-day trial access 

    Abu Dhabi National Oil Company (Adnoc) has completed the transaction to acquire a majority stake in UAE-headquartered Fertiglobe, the largest nitrogen-based fertiliser producer in the Middle East and North Africa region.

    Adnoc has increased its shareholding in Fertiglobe to 86.2% through the acquisition of 50% + 1 share held by Netherlands-based OCI Global, which is backed by Egyptian billionaire Nassef Sawiris. The Abu Dhabi energy giant previously held a 36.2% stake in Fertiglobe.

    The remaining 13.8% of Fertiglobe’s shares trade on the Abu Dhabi Securities Exchange following the company's stock listing in October 2022.

    Adnoc announced the transaction to become the majority shareholder in Fertiglobe last December. Fertiglobe’s shares were priced at AED3.2 ($0.87) a share, valuing the deal at $3.62bn.

    Following the completion of the majority acquisition, “Fertiglobe’s current management team will stay in place”, including Ahmed El-Hoshy in his role as CEO, Adnoc said in a statement on 15 October.

    “Ahmed El-Hoshy spent 15 years growing OCI’s US and European business in ammonia and methanol via greenfields, brownfields and acquisitions, generating significant value for shareholders by leading recent divestments,” Adnoc said.

    Growing chemicals business

    Fertiglobe is the world’s largest seaborne exporter of urea and ammonia combined, exporting to 53 countries with a collective market share of about 10% of global trade in these products.

    “The acquisition represents … the expansion of Adnoc’s low-carbon fuels business, and supports its goal to become a top-five global chemicals player,” Adnoc said.

    “Fertiglobe will become the platform for Adnoc’s growth in fertiliser and low-carbon ammonia,” Adnoc said in its statement.

    Adnoc added it will transfer its stakes in existing and future low-carbon ammonia projects to Fertiglobe “at cost and when ready for startup”, including its two projects in Abu Dhabi and other projects in its global portfolio. Adnoc has yet to specify the low-carbon ammonia and blue ammonia production projects.

    MEED understands that the first Abu Dhabi project in question is the blue ammonia facility in the Taziz Industrial Chemicals Zone in Ruwais. Fertiglobe has partnered with South Korea’s GS Energy Corporation and Japanese investment firm Mitsui & Company to build the complex, which will have a production capacity of 1 million tonnes a year (t/y).

    In February last year, the joint venture awarded Italian firm Tecnimont the main contract for executing the engineering, procurement and construction works on the Taziz blue ammonia project.

    The second Abu Dhabi blue ammonia project that Adnoc could be referring to in its statement is a proposed scheme for which it signed a joint feasibility study agreement with British energy producer BP in May 2022.

    Adnoc further said that the two projects in Abu Dhabi will add 2 million t/y of output potential, more than doubling Fertiglobe’s current commercial ammonia capacity of 1.6 million t/y and increasing its total sellable capacity to 8.6 million t/y of net ammonia and urea combined, in addition to other announced global projects.

    https://image.digitalinsightresearch.in/uploads/NewsArticle/12735570/main1542.jpg
    Indrajit Sen
  • Neom receives interest for Magna coastal highway

    16 October 2024

     

    Saudi Arabia’s gigaproject developer Neom has received interest from firms for the contract to build a coastal highway and infrastructure project linking Neom to the Magna development on the Gulf of Aqaba.

    The project, called Magna Infrastructure Packages, is split into three. 

    Package 1 is 13 kilometres, package 2 is 42km and package 3 is 41km.

    The packages cater to the development’s north, central and south areas.

    According to an industry source, the design-and-build project covers utilities for water, power, mobility, sewer, buildings and highways. It could cost between $250m and $500m.

    Local and international engineering, procurement and construction (EPC) contractors are understood to have submitted their expressions of interest to participate in the tender on 15 October.

    The coastal highway and infrastructure project is expected to be completed by 2027, the source said.

    Magna consists of 12 developments featuring 15 hotels that offer 1,600 hotel rooms, suites and apartments and over 2,500 residences.

    The development will span a 120km-long coastal strip with an average width of 3.5km. The total land area is about 430 square kilometres.

    The Magna infrastructure is divided into six districts, as follows:

    • District 1 – Northern Gateway: includes 13 bridges and underpasses with a length of 1.9km, 18 wadi culverts and five drainage culverts
    • District 2 – Romantic Bay and the Cube: includes two bridges and underpasses spanning 360 metres, 40 wadi culverts and 24 drainage culverts
    • District 3 – Wadi Tayyib: includes two bridges and underpasses, 26 wadi culverts and nine drainage culverts
    • District 4 – Jungle Club: includes three bridges and underpasses and 17 wadi culverts
    • District 5 – Magna: includes two bridges and underpasses, 14 wadi culverts and two drainage culverts
    • District 6 – Southern Gateway: includes three bridges and underpasses, 31 wadi culverts and one drainage culvert
    https://image.digitalinsightresearch.in/uploads/NewsArticle/12735899/main.jpg
    Jennifer Aguinaldo