Saudi economy shows signs of weakness

3 August 2023


The Saudi economy is showing signs of weakness as negative growth in the oil economy overshadows the positive growth registered by the non-oil economy.

On 31 July, London-based Capital Economics said the Saudi economy was now technically in recession after the kingdom's General Authority for Statistics (Gastat) confirmed that the economy contracted during the second quarter of this year with the publication of its GDP Flash Estimates.

The estimates show that the Saudi economy contracted by 0.1 per cent during the second quarter of this year compared to the first quarter. Real GDP declined by 1.4 per cent in the first quarter compared to the fourth quarter of 2022.

The statistics look more encouraging on an annual basis. Real GDP increased by 1.1 per cent during the second quarter of 2023 compared to the same period in 2022. The non-oil economy grew by 5.5 per cent in the second quarter compared to the same period last year, while the oil economy decreased by 4.2 per cent compared to the previous year. During the first quarter of this year, growth was 3.8 per cent compared to the first quarter of 2022. 

Projects performance

The projects market has also performed strongly during the first half of the year. According to regional projects tracker MEED Projects, $42bn of deals were signed, the most on record. The previous high was the $28bn awarded during the first half of 2014.

Capital Economics said the technical recession was mainly due to reductions in oil production, despite the non-oil economy maintaining strong growth. The oil economy contracted by 1.4 per cent during the second quarter on a quarter-on-quarter basis, while the non-oil economy increased by 2 per cent.

Looking to the future, Saudi Arabia has adopted even more stringent cuts to its oil production in the third quarter, with an additional voluntary reduction of one million barrels a day in July and August.

Capital Economics expects this to counter further strength in the non-oil sector, leading to an anticipated contraction in GDP of about 3 per cent quarter-on-quarter in the third quarter. It also says there is a growing possibility that the upcoming Opec+’s Joint Ministerial Monitoring Committee meeting will result in the kingdom announcing the extension of this voluntary cut until at least the end of September.

If this occurs, the economy is expected to shrink by about 0.5 per cent over 2023. Excluding the global financial crisis and pandemic, this would mark the poorest GDP performance in over two decades.

IMF downgrade

The economic data for the second quarter was released shortly after the Washington-based IMF downgraded its real GDP growth projection for Saudi Arabia in 2023 to 1.9 per cent in its latest World Economic Outlook update.

The fund had in April anticipated a growth rate of 3.1 per cent for the year, adjusting this forecast to 2.1 per cent in June due to global macroeconomic concerns and uncertainties in oil demand.

The downward revision in Saudi Arabia’s growth forecast has broader implications for the wider Middle East region, which the IMF now expects to grow by 2.6 per cent in 2023, down from 3.1 per cent in its April forecast.

The slump in Saudi Arabia’s economic output contrasts strongly with its performance in 2022, when its growth was gauged at 8.7 per cent by the IMF, driven by a boost in oil revenue amid high energy prices. The kingdom also achieved its first budget surplus in almost a decade.

The signs of weakness in the Saudi economy coincide with reports of losses for the Public Investment Fund (PIF), which is driving much of the development of the non-oil economy in the kingdom. According to a report by Bloomberg, it made an investment activity loss of about $11bn in 2022, in sharp contrast to the $19bn profit reported the previous year. Despite the loss on investment activity made last year, PIF’s total assets grew from $676bn to about $778bn in 2022.

The PIF and its subsidiary companies are leading the development of a wide range of projects in the kingdom, including five official gigaproject developers. They are Neom, Red Sea Global, Roshn, Qiddiya and Diriyah.

Debt markets

The investment losses and the ramp-up of spending on domestic projects mean the PIF is likely to raise more debt. According to another report by Bloomberg, the fund has hired banks for a debut Islamic dollar bond sale to help finance its global spending plans. The fund could raise about $3bn, although the final size of the sukuk could be bigger depending on investor demand. It has mandated HSBC, Standard Chartered, Emirates NBD Bank and Al-Rajhi Capital for the offering.

As of the end of 2022, the fund’s borrowings amounted to $85bn. Earlier this year, it secured $5.5bn with a three-tranche green bond sale.
Colin Foreman
Related Articles
  • Net zero steps need recalibration

    22 April 2024

    After more than 100 countries supported a global commitment to triple renewable energy capacity by 2030 at Cop28, policy makers, offtakers and transmission system operators (TSO) are coming to grips with the hard questions implementing such commitment entails.

    Carlos Gasco Travesedo, energy policy executive director at the Department of Energy (DoE), told the World Future Energy Summit in Abu Dhabi in mid-April that a distinction must be made between tripling renewable energy capacity and increasing renewable power that can be absorbed and transported by electricity grids without compromising their efficiency and stability.

    There is a consensus among stakeholders that new technologies and approaches such as battery energy storage systems, international grid connectivity and a more pervasive use of digital technologies, particularly those powered by artificial intelligence, could provide some answers to enabling the successful integration of more clean energy into the electricity production mix.

    The adoption of technology is crucial towards meeting the 2050 or 2060 net-zero targets across jurisdictions as well as the intervening 2030 or 2035 lower greenhouse gas emissions commitments.

    Each solution requires regulations and investments that may guarantee they will remain relevant 10 or 20 years down the road as new technologies emerge.

    For example, while some experts say that grid connectivity is essential to load balancing and in achieving sustainability in power systems, others say that such a solution is not commercially viable and will also require unifying grid codes between countries.

    Battery energy storage systems, long seen as a solution to the intermittency of solar and wind farms, are now being positioned to address spinning reserves due to their ability to store and discharge energy from various sources when needed. Yet, batteries remain relatively expensive, negating to a large extent one of the key energy security pillars.

    These scenarios reinforce the role of natural gas – which has half the polluting capacity of coal – as a transition fuel, in view of the costs and risks associated with another competing technology, nuclear energy. Note must be made, however, that natural gas itself is part of the fossil fuel troika that countries have committed to transition away from at Cop28.

    By all accounts, the perfect solution to ensure future power systems dominated by clean energy that are affordable and reliable remains elusive and will likely remain so for a while longer.

    As one senior executive with an international utility developer tells MEED, there is no playbook that exists, which someone can follow confidently.

    This implies that the transition must proceed gradually from the current environment. Only such process can prove, or disprove, that a mix of solar, nuclear, wind and hydrogen is indeed the holy grail of energy transition.

    Related reads:
    Jennifer Aguinaldo
  • Rainmaking in the world economy

    19 April 2024

    Edmund O'Sullivan
    Former editor of MEED

    The biennial IMF World Economic Outlook released on 16 April forecasts that global growth will hold steady at just over 3% in 2024.

    That is despite Russia’s war on Ukraine and the risk that Israel’s war on Gaza will trigger a regional conflict and jeopardise oil exports from the region.

    This is an unexpected prospect – rather like a meteorologist forecasting that the UAE will get the equivalent of a year’s rainfall in a single day, as it did in mid-April.

    A soft landing for the world economy despite the risks is by that standard less surprising. But these things don’t just happen.

    Just as the UAE’s greatest flooding incident since records began was exacerbated by creeping climate change, according to experts, global growth is believed to be robust because of determined action to keep prices down, cut inflation and boost the supply of goods and labour.

    The challenge to the rosy outlook, however, is not hard to find. Several key stress factors are in the US.

    The biggest threat to the IMF’s forecast is from events in the Middle East

    American fiscal policy under President Joe Biden has been extremely loose. The US budget deficit to 2030 is forecast to average 6% of GDP. Its debt-to-GDP ratio – now above 100% – will rise for the foreseeable future.

    Even the IMF, always reluctant to criticise its biggest shareholder, says this looks unsustainable. 

    More than 3 million migrants arrived in the US last year and the proportion of foreign-born residents in America is approaching an historic high. A more contentious issue is that more than 2 million undocumented migrants also entered the US in 2023 and the figure is rising.

    Donald Trump is making migration an issue in his campaign to regain the White House. This is fuelling concern among US voters that could precipitate restrictions on immigration.

    The biggest threat to the IMF’s forecast is from events in the Middle East. On the night of 13 April, Iran launched drones and missiles on Israel in retaliation for its attack on Tehran’s Damascus consulate two weeks earlier.

    Oil prices spiked ahead of Iran’s attack and eased back on expectations that there would be no wider regional conflagration. But higher levels of risk are being built in to forecasts of oil prices, which are around a quarter higher than they were in January. Even without an escalation, oil is heading towards $100 a barrel this summer.

    This doesn’t have to happen, however. With concerted international diplomatic efforts on stage and behind the scenes, the world has the capacity to block the path to a new Middle East war and all it entails. 

    But does it have the will? 

    Main image: Flooding in Dubai remains three days after the severe storm on 16 April  

    Connect with Edmund O’Sullivan on Twitter

    More from Edmund O’Sullivan:

    New shock treatment for Egypt’s economy
    Syria’s long march in from the cold
    Lebanon’s pain captured in a call from Beirut
    Troubled end to 2023 bodes ill for stability
    The Holy Land and delusions it inspires
    Region to mark golden jubilee of 1973 war
    Gulf funds help reshape football
    When a war crime is denied
    Embracing the new Washington consensus
    Trump, Turkiye and the trouble ahead
    Edmund O’Sullivan
  • Masdar and Etihad plan pumped hydro project

    19 April 2024

    Abu Dhabi Future Energy Company (Masdar) and Etihad Water & Electricity (Ethad WE) have signed a memorandum of understanding (MoU) to develop several clean energy projects in the UAE's northern emirates.

    The planned projects include a solar photovoltaic (PV) project, a pumped hydro storage project and a potential battery energy storage system facility.

    The two companies signed the MoU on 18 April, the final day of the World Future Energy Summit in Abu Dhabi.

    "This agreement aims to formalise the intention of the parties to further discuss the potential areas of collaboration and possible projects," Masdar said in a social media post.

    Etihad WE is responsible for the procurement and offtake of water and power production services in Umm Al Quwain, Ras Al Khaimah, Ajman and parts of Sharjah.

    Masdar and Emirates Global Aluminium (EGA) announced an agreement to work together on aluminium decarbonisation and low-carbon aluminium growth opportunities during the same event.

    As part of the agreement, Masdar and EGA will also work together internationally to find opportunities through which Masdar will support EGA to power new aluminium production facilities with renewable energy sources.
    Jennifer Aguinaldo
  • Ewec signs Ajban solar PV contract

    19 April 2024

    Abu Dhabi state utility Emirates Water & Electricity Company (Ewec) has signed an agreement for the development and operation of Abu Dhabi’s third utility-scale solar photovoltaic (PV) independent power project (IPP).

    A team led by French utility developer EDF Renewables and including South Korea's Korea Western Power Company (Kowepo) won the 1,500MW Al Ajban solar PV IPP contract.

    Ewec announced the official signing of the contract on 18 April, the final day of the World Future Energy Summit in Abu Dhabi.

    As with previous solar PV projects in the emirate, Abu Dhabi Future Energy Company (Masdar) will own a stake in the special purpose vehicle that will implement the project.

    It is the second major contract won by the French-South Korean team in the GCC since March last year. The team previously won the contract to develop and operate the 500MW Manah 1 solar IPP in Oman.

    EDF, along with Masdar and Saudi contracting company Nesma, also won the contract to develop and operate the 1,100MW Hinakiyah solar IPP project in Saudi Arabia in November.

    The EDF-led team submitted the lowest levelised electricity cost of 5.1921 fils a kilowatt-hour (kWh) or about 1.413 $cents/kWh for the Al Ajban solar PV IPP contract, as MEED reported in July 2023.

    Japan’s Marubeni submitted the second-lowest bid of 5.3577 fils/kWh.

    Ewec requested proposals for the contract in January 2023 and received bids in late June 2023. It qualified 19 companies to bid for the contract in September 2022.

    Delivering goals

    The Al Ajban project – similar to the 1,584MW Al Dhafra solar IPP, which was inaugurated in November, and the operational 935MW Noor Abu Dhabi plant – supports the UAE Energy Strategy 2050 and the UAE Net-Zero by 2050 strategic initiative.

    Ewec aims to install up to 17GW of solar PV capacity by 2035.

    The plan will require the procurement of about 1.5GW of capacity annually over the next 10 years. Over the intervening period, ending in 2030, Ewec plans to have an additional 5GW of solar capacity, reaching a total solar installed capacity of 7.3GW by 2030.

    Ewec expects its first battery energy storage system to come online in the late 2020s to boost balancing the grid's load as more renewable energy enters the system.

    The UAE published its updated national energy strategy in July last year. It includes a plan to triple the nationwide renewable energy capacity to 19GW by 2030.
    Jennifer Aguinaldo
  • Egypt resumes power cuts

    18 April 2024

    Power cuts resumed across Egypt on 15 April, with scheduled power outages lasting a maximum of one hour per grid zone between 11am and 5pm daily.

    The scheduled power outages began last year and were suspended during Ramadan.

    The electricity ministry has confirmed that, since no new amendments to the load reduction plan have been issued, the power cut plan will continue indefinitely, adding that the outages are expected to last "until at least the end of summer, due to increased grid demand during the hotter months".

    The government-initiated load-shedding programme initially aimed to rein in rising electricity consumption and reduce pressure on the country's gas network.

    According to the country’s Electricity & Renewable Energy Ministry, national electricity consumption reached 43,650MW in mid-July last year, up significantly from previous highs of about 31,000MW.

    While the record-high consumption level is still below the official generation installed capacity of close to 60,000MW, consumption levels of 34,000MW–36,000MW will require about 129-146 million cubic metres of gas and diesel a day.

    Barring load-shedding, any increase in consumption beyond 36,000MW will require a commensurate increase in gas and diesel, which is understood to be beyond the government’s capacity to procure.

    Crucially, the other side of the electricity rationing initiative has to do with the need to save gas for exports, to boost the government’s dollar reserves in the face of the ongoing currency crisis.

    MEED’s latest special report on Egypt includes:

    Cairo secures a cumulative $54bn in financing
    Egypt faces political and economic trials

    Cairo beset by regional geopolitical storm
    More pain for more gain for Egypt
    Egypt oil and gas project activity declines
    Familiar realities threaten Egypt’s energy hub ambitions
    Egypt’s desalination projects inch forward
    > Infrastructure carries Egypt construction
    Jennifer Aguinaldo