meed-logo

line1 line2 line3
SIGN IN / REGISTER

Bankability remains hydrogen’s unbreakable challenge

6 February 2025

Commentary
Jennifer Aguinaldo
Energy & technology editor

There is some indication that green hydrogen as an industry has arrived at the valley of disillusionment if the Gartner hype cycle is anything to go by.

This is evident with the dwindling number of attendees and absence of offtakers – global commodity trading companies that are expected to buy premium green hydrogen and derivative products – at previously well-attended green hydrogen summits in major cities in the Gulf.

Following frenzied announcements of multibillion-dollar integrated green hydrogen and ammonia plants in the Middle East and North Africa region, particularly Egypt, Morocco, Oman and the UAE, between 2021 and 2023, it appears that key stakeholders have started coming to grips with reality.

Of the close to 80 green hydrogen projects that MEED and MEED Projects track, only three have so far signed an offtake agreement, and only one has managed to reach financial close.

The $8.4bn Neom green hydrogen project in Saudi Arabia reached financial close in March 2023, nearly two years after it was announced.

The project, the largest of its kind requiring over 4GW of renewable energy and 2GW of electrolyser capacity, managed to reach financial close based on one of the three co-developers, the US’ Air Products, assuming the full offtake and construction risks for the project, note some experts.

A project’s bankability ultimately relies on suitable stakeholders taking on the risks for every aspect of the project, from construction to operations.

Currently, the risks or threats include evolving global regulations related to consumption and carbon emissions pricing; lack of technology maturity; supply and demand uncertainty; and the lack of mainstream demand, according to Wael Almazeedi, chief executive at Abu Dhabi-based International Renewable Energy Certification (I-rec) certified firm Avance Energy.

Almazeedi said these risks “need to be mitigated to the satisfaction of project lenders” if the planned green hydrogen projects in the region are to secure financing and reach the construction phase.

The challenges do not necessarily mean all projects will fail, however.

Similar to predecessors such as solar and electrification technologies, the hope is for the planned green hydrogen projects to eventually emerge out of the realm of disillusionment and reach the so-called enlightenment slope and, ultimately, plateaus of productivity, using Gartner’s hype cycle model.

Government support in terms of regulatory frameworks, inevitably including some form of subsidies to bridge the so-called green premium, as well as global certification standards, are at the top of suppliers’ agendas. 

Across the key aspiring Mena clean hydrogen hubs, like the UAE in particular, clearer regulatory frameworks have started to emerge, which could encourage more cohesive cooperation and enable projects to get off the ground.

Key EU countries also appear to remain committed to clean and green hydrogen imports as part of the green deal, while at least one power plant in Japan has completed a three-month trial of co-firing green ammonia with coal “with positive results”.  

But until all these come together to ensure an unencumbered global supply chain, offtakers and project financing deals will likely remain elusive. 

Related reads:

READ THE FEBRUARY MEED BUSINESS REVIEW

Trump unleashes tech opportunities; Doha achieves diplomatic prowess and economic resilience; GCC water developers eye uptick in award activity in 2025.

Published on 1 February 2025 and distributed to senior decision-makers in the region and around the world, the February MEED Business Review includes:

> WATER & WASTEWATER: Water projects require innovation
https://image.digitalinsightresearch.in/uploads/NewsArticle/13370135/main.gif
Jennifer Aguinaldo

Register for MEED's guest program now to access this article.

Click here to register
Exclusive from Meed
Related Articles
  • Iraq and GE Vernova complete several plants’ upgrade

    6 February 2025

    US-headquartered energy technology provider GE Vernova has completed upgrades of "several key" power plants in Iraq.

    The firm and the Iraqi Ministry of Electricity announced the upgrade's completion on 5 February.

    The overall upgrade project, which GE Vernova previously announced, covers 46 gas turbines across 12 power plants, which will add up to 500MW to Iraq's national grid before the summer of 2025.

    They did not specify which power plants have completed upgrade works.  

    According to GE, some of the power plants included in this project already transitioned from heavy fuel oil (HFO) to natural gas, with a capacity increase of approximately 260MW. These plants include Ninawa, Al-Diwaniyah, Hilla, Karbala, Shat Al-Basra, Najibiya, Samawa, Dhiqar, Al-Khairat and Al-Haidariya.

    GE Vernova added: "The other plants are expected to be modernised within the summer of 2025, with an expected additional increase in capacity of approximately 250MW.

    "This modernisation is expected to improve operational flexibility and boost output, efficiency, and availability of the power generation assets."

    In addition, the firm announced the successful installation of its Advanced Gas Path (AGP) upgrades on several 9. E gas turbines powering the Al-Quds and Dhiqar power plants, and MXLII upgrades on 13E2 gas turbines powering Al- Mansouriya power plant.

    According to GE Vernova, the expected output increases of up to 6% for each of these power plants will enable Iraq's Ministry of Electricity (MoE) to generate more electricity using the same amount of fuel.

    In addition, as part of the services and upgrade agreement announced in 2024 with MoE to enhance the availability of power plants across the country, GE Vernova completed comprehensive maintenance projects across several of these power plants corresponding to a total capacity of 3.7GW.

    These power plants include Qayyarah, Diwaniyah, Al-Haydariyah and Baghdad South. 

    Iraq periodically suffers from power outages, especially during the summer months when increased cooling requirements overwhelm its power plants and electricity grid.  

    https://image.digitalinsightresearch.in/uploads/NewsArticle/13370380/main.jpg
    Jennifer Aguinaldo
  • Morocco explores salt caverns for hydrogen storage

    6 February 2025

     

    A feasibility study is under way for a project to explore underground salt cavern sites for green hydrogen storage in Morocco.

    According to Samir Rachidi, director-general at Iresen, the underground salt caverns are located near the capital Casablanca.

    “There is already an existing cavity used to store natural gas,” Rachidi told MEED.

    It is understood the same process or principle will be used to store green hydrogen in salt caverns.

    The potential storage capacity of the salt caverns for green hydrogen can only be determined once the feasibility study is completed.  

    Photo credit: Shutterstock

    Underground salt caverns offer an option for the bulk storage of very large amounts of gaseous hydrogen.

    According to Ireland-headquartered chemicals firm Linde, which operates the world’s first commercial hydrogen high-purity cavern in Texas, the gas has to be purified and compressed before it can be injected into a cavern.

    It added that hydrogen-filled cavities can act as a backup for a pipeline network.

    First green ammonia project

    Rachidi also said that Moroccan phosphate specialist OCP is in the advanced stages of studying a project to produce 1 million tonnes of green ammonia annually by 2027.

    The planned facility, which will cater to export markets, will include a 200,000 tonne-a-year (t/y) green hydrogen production plant and 4,000MW of renewable energy plants.

    It will also include an electrolyser plant with a capacity of 2,000MW.

    At least seven other green hydrogen or ammonia projects are under study or in the pre-front-end engineering and design stage in the North African state.

    In April 2023, a team led by China Energy International Construction Group signed a memorandum of cooperation to develop a green hydrogen project in a coastal area in southern Morocco.

    A year earlier, Serbia-headquartered renewables developer and investor CWP Global appointed US firm Bechtel to support the development of large-scale green hydrogen and ammonia facilities in Morocco and Mauritania.

    The Amun green hydrogen project, which CWP Global plans to develop in Morocco, is understood to require 15GW of renewable energy and has an estimated budget of between $18bn and $20bn.

    Morocco established a National Hydrogen Commission in 2019 and published a green hydrogen roadmap in 2021. 

    The roadmap entails the production of green hydrogen for local ammonia production and export between 2020 and 2030; the production and export of green hydrogen, green ammonia and synthetic fuels between 2030 and 2040; and the global trade of these products between 2040 and 2050.   

    Main photo: For illustrative purposes only (Adnoc)

    READ THE FEBRUARY MEED BUSINESS REVIEW

    Trump unleashes tech opportunities; Doha achieves diplomatic prowess and economic resilience; GCC water developers eye uptick in award activity in 2025.

    Published on 1 February 2025 and distributed to senior decision-makers in the region and around the world, the February MEED Business Review includes:

    > WATER & WASTEWATER: Water projects require innovation
    https://image.digitalinsightresearch.in/uploads/NewsArticle/13369568/main.jpg
    Jennifer Aguinaldo
  • Qatar maintains stable growth heading

    6 February 2025

    https://image.digitalinsightresearch.in/uploads/NewsArticle/13369431/main.gif
    MEED Editorial
  • SWPC and Acwa Power sign Ras Mohaisen contract

    6 February 2025

    State utility offtaker Saudi Water Partnership Company (SWPC) has awarded a contract to develop the Ras Mohaisen independent water project (IWP) in Saudi Arabia to a consortium led by Riyadh-headquartered utility developer Acwa Power.

    The state water offtaker received two bids for the contract in April last year.

    Spain’s Acciona was the only other company that submitted a proposal for the contract.

    The Ras Mohaisen IWP will be able to treat 300,000 cubic metres of seawater a day (cm/d) using reverse osmosis technology.

    It will also include storage tanks with a capacity of 600,000 cubic metres, equivalent to two operating days, and an electrical substation.

    The build, own and operate project is expected to reach commercial operation by the second quarter of 2028.

    The developer consortium includes local firms Hajj Abdullah Ali Reza & Partners and Al-Kifah Holding Company. 

    The plant will be located in Al-Qunfudhah Governorate, about 300 kilometres south of Mecca, on the Red Sea coast in Saudi Arabia’s Western Region.

    Netherlands-headquartered KPMG acted as SWPC’s financial adviser, with UK-based Eversheds Sutherland acting as the legal adviser for the project.

    Prince Hussam Bin Saud Bin Abdulaziz, emir of the Al-Baha region, and Abdulrahman Bin Abdulmohsen AlFadley, minister of environment, water and agriculture and chairman of the SWPC board of directors, signed the Ras Mohaisen IWP project agreements.

    AlFadley said the project will enhance water supply chains and is intended to serve the Mecca and Al-Baha regions.

    READ THE FEBRUARY MEED BUSINESS REVIEW

    Trump unleashes tech opportunities; Doha achieves diplomatic prowess and economic resilience; GCC water developers eye uptick in award activity in 2025.

    Published on 1 February 2025 and distributed to senior decision-makers in the region and around the world, the February MEED Business Review includes:

    > WATER & WASTEWATER: Water projects require innovation
    https://image.digitalinsightresearch.in/uploads/NewsArticle/13369351/main.jpg
    Jennifer Aguinaldo
  • Tech takes centre stage

    6 February 2025

    Commentary
    Colin Foreman
    Editor

    Read the February MEED Business Review

    An incoming US president always presents new challenges for the region as leaders adjust to shifting policies emanating from Washington.

    In 2025, the situation is different. It is the first time since Grover Cleveland in 1893 that a former US president has returned to office after a period away from the White House. In theory, this means that although the presidency has changed, it is a president the region has worked with before and should be familiar with.

    In practice, Donald Trump proved unpredictable during his first term, with significant challenges emerging for the region. During his 2017-20 presidency, the Gulf diplomatic dispute with Qatar began, the nuclear deal with Iran was scrapped and the Abraham Accords were signed.

    Trump also proved to be transactional and pro-business. During the early days of Trump 2.0, there have been clear signals that the new administration will have a different approach when dealing with big tech and the ever-expanding role of China in the global economy.

    The Gulf has already identified that the tech sector plays to the region’s strengths and promises to solve many of its structural economic challenges. The region is rich in energy and capital and has begun to invest heavily in the expensive business of developing artificial intelligence (AI) and power-hungry data centres.

    Both have already aligned with Trump 2.0, with Damac founder and chairman Hussain Sajwani committing $20bn to data centres across the US and Abu Dhabi-backed Stargate announcing $500bn of investment in AI in what Trump calls the largest AI deal in history by far.

    The speed with which these deals were announced shows that the pragmatic business and political leaders in the Gulf have already responded to the change in administration at the White House. The challenge now shifts to maintaining the positive momentum with a president who is notoriously difficult to predict.

    READ THE FEBRUARY MEED BUSINESS REVIEW

    Trump unleashes tech opportunities; Doha achieves diplomatic prowess and economic resilience; GCC water developers eye uptick in award activity in 2025.

    Published on 1 February 2025 and distributed to senior decision-makers in the region and around the world, the February MEED Business Review includes:

    > WATER & WASTEWATER: Water projects require innovation
    https://image.digitalinsightresearch.in/uploads/NewsArticle/13369338/main.gif
    Colin Foreman