meed-logo

line1 line2 line3
SIGN IN / REGISTER

GCC banks navigate Credit Suisse fallout

31 March 2023

 

Saudi National Bank chairman Ammar al-Khudairy’s abrupt resignation on 27 March capped a turbulent few weeks for the world’s financial system. This period saw the kingdom’s champion bank dragged into the harsh glare of the global spotlight and serious questions asked about Gulf financial institutions’ readiness to serve as props in an increasingly jumpy financial order.

A short sentence uttered in an interview by a senior Saudi banker precipitated the collapse of a 160-year-old institution. Ruling out extending beyond its 10 per cent stake as it would entail a higher capital cost led to the fellow Swiss bank UBS buying the troubled lender at a steep discount.

Al-Khudairy took the rap for what was deemed an avoidable crisis, in which SNB took a hosing: it bought the Credit Suisse stock at CHF3.82 ($4.2) a share; UBS has paid just CHF0.76 ($0.83) a share.

The pain goes wider than SNB and the Qatar Investment Authority (QIA), the other Gulf institution directly impacted by Credit Suisse’s troubles, given its 6.9 per cent stake in the lender.

The crisis poses serious questions about the role of wealthy Gulf institutions in a global system that is increasingly reliant on them, but has yet to stress test the relationship.

On the one hand, Gulf investors have been spooked about their exposure to venerable banking institutions that were once seen as copper-bottomed plays. Conversely, Western banks may now legitimately ask whether their Gulf counterparts are reliable partners in a crisis.

Volatile landscape

The backdrop is one of wider concern about the health of global financial markets. The Credit Suisse crisis was prefaced by US regulators shutting Silicon Valley Bank (SVB) on 10 March, following mass withdrawals of customer deposits.

For now, analysts caution against panic. First, SNB’s exposure – and that of other prominent Gulf lenders – appears limited.

“The impact of SNB’s investment in Credit Suisse and the subsequent takeover by UBS on SNB are limited because the initial investment represents less than 2 per cent of SNB’s investment portfolio and 70-80 bps of the bank’s risk-adjusted capital ratio,” says Mohamed Damak, senior director, Financial Institutions Ratings, at ratings agency S&P.

As to problems in the Western markets, again, exposures are manageable. “On average, banks we rate in GCC had exposure to the US of 4.6 per cent of assets and 2.3 per cent of liabilities at year-end 2022,” says Damak.

“Generally, GCC banks would have limited lending activity in the US and most of their assets there would be in high-credit quality instruments or with the Federal Reserve. The exposure to Europe tends to be limited as well, except for banks that have a presence in some European countries like France or the UK. Most of the activity in these jurisdictions tends to be linked to home countries or generally made of high-quality exposures.”

This will not end SNB shareholder anxiety that the bank’s raison d’etre – supporting domestic projects related to Vision 2030 – had been sidelined in the pursuit of equity positions in global blue chips.

Qatari contagion

Similar questions will be asked in Qatar, where the QIA provided ballast for the Swiss bank’s balance sheet in 2021, when it issued $2bn in convertible notes. The Qatari wealth fund will be reviewing its bank holdings and stress-testing its wider portfolio.

Others will do the same. “Gulf sovereign wealth funds will probably review their asset allocations, regardless of this current crisis,” one Gulf-based economist tells MEED. “The reality is that their role is changing. They were, in the past, more opportunistic investors. Today they are becoming strategic vehicles.”

If Gulf funds like QIA will no longer serve as the global financial system’s white knights – as they proved in the 2008 financial crisis – this may prompt a reconfiguration of investment strategies.

There will be a steep learning curve, says one Gulf-based economist – on both sides.

Governance implications

In light of the growing financial strength of the Gulf institutions come new responsibilities and governance requirements, reflecting the dawning reality that Gulf institutions are growing into increasingly globally systemically significant investors or sources of capital.

“They need to act accordingly,” says the economist. “Not just from the global governance perspective, but also from the perspective of protecting their assets.”

Gulf institutions’ transformation into opportunistic investors was well-timed when liquidity was required at short notice.

“The money centres of the world turned to one of the biggest honey pots they could identify. And, of course, some of the old reservations were conveniently parked aside, at least for the time being,” says the economist.

The challenge for the Gulf institutions was the lack of deep experience or institutional frameworks needed to underpin those initial investments.

“Opportunities arose, these countries chose to take them and they got lucky because they helped stabilise the global financial system, and they helped protect the reputation of these institutions. And no major mistakes were made. But that initial opportunistic approach will no longer fly,” says the economist.

Gulf sector outlook

The Credit Suisse saga has also prompted much ruminating in Western media to the extent that Western institutions may cast a more wary eye in future over their Gulf counterparts.

But absent new funding sources, the GCC's appeal may prove irresistible to them. After all, says the economist, beggars can’t be choosers.

“What is the alternative to resorting to institutions such as the Gulf sovereign funds? They’re not going to go to China, that’s for sure. The only real alternative is to get some sort of a backstop from national central banks. And that is pretty much as close as you can get to a moral hazard,” he says.

The broader global picture is evolving. How Gulf institutions related to primarily Western institutions will also be influenced by the change in the GCC states’ foreign policy.

Gulf governments are increasingly cognisant of the need for a balanced, multi-directional foreign policy. And that is something they will also want to reflect in their wealth funds and banks’ investment behaviour.

The next year should provide an insight into how the post-Credit Suisse modus vivendi will play out.

https://image.digitalinsightresearch.in/uploads/NewsArticle/10724320/main2803.jpg
James Gavin

Register for MEED's guest program now to access this article.

Click here to register
Exclusive from Meed
Related Articles
  • UAE rides high on non-oil boom

    26 April 2024

    Commentary
    John Bambridge
    Analysis editor

    The UAE has demonstrated remarkable economic resilience in recent years, with its non-oil sector bouncing back relatively quickly from Covid-19 and emerging as the real driving force behind the country’s growth. 

    Despite slower oil activity due to the Opec+ oil production cuts and regional turmoil, the non-oil sector has continued to go from strength to strength and is enjoying a resurgent boom in its real estate sector, with levels of activity not seen since before the 2008 global financial crash.

    Among the other drivers of UAE non-oil growth are the country’s rapid expansion and rollout of free trade agreements, with it having signed comprehensive economic partnership deals with 12 countries to date. In the absence of much progress on GCC-wide trade agreements, Abu Dhabi is opening itself up to greater trade opportunities with other markets. 

    Another significant recent development was the UAE’s removal from the Financial Action Task Force’s ‘grey list’ in 2024, which has bolstered investor confidence and general business sentiment.

    On the projects side, there is a real estate and construction boom, with over $475bn-worth of private real estate developments and public building and housing programmes planned or under way. Transport schemes at the top of the agenda include the UAE-Oman rail scheme and a high-speed rail link connecting Abu Dhabi and Dubai.

    Also in the works is the $22bn Dubai Strategic Sewerage Tunnel project. Such a network would have served the city well in mid-April, when its infrastructure fared poorly against the hardest rainfall in 75 years.

    On the oil side of the economy, Abu Dhabi National Oil Company (Adnoc) remains committed to expanding its upstream operations and is expected to maintain robust spending on key projects in 2024. Close to $8bn-worth of combined midstream, downstream and petrochemicals contracts are also expected to be awarded this year.

    The conflict in Gaza poses an increasingly serious challenge to the region, however. The UAE has so far remained relatively quiescent on the conflict while concentrating on humanitarian operations. The country is clearly keen to retain the economic benefits that it has been enjoying since its normalisation of ties with Israel under the Abraham Accords.

    The newly kindled relationship is being tested, however, with the airstrike on the aid convoy of the World Central Kitchen drawing some of the harshest words from Abu Dhabi towards Tel Aviv to date. 

    The risk of rising escalation with Iran meanwhile could quickly quench the current exuberance of the UAE’s buoyant non-oil sector.

     

    MEED's April 2024 special report on the UAE includes:

    > GVT & ECONOMY: Non-oil activity underpins UAE economy
    > BANKING: UAE banks seize the moment
    > UPSTREAM: Adnoc oil and gas project spending sees steep uptick
    > DOWNSTREAM: UAE builds its downstream and chemicals potential
    > POWER: UAE marks successful power project deliveries
    > WATER: Dubai tunnels project dominates UAE pipeline
    > DUBAI CONSTRUCTION: Dubai real estate boosts construction sector
    > ABU DHABI CONSTRUCTION: Abu Dhabi makes major construction investments

    https://image.digitalinsightresearch.in/uploads/NewsArticle/11705846/main.gif
    John Bambridge
  • Morocco seeks firms for 400MW wind schemes

    26 April 2024

    The Moroccan Agency for Sustainable Energy (Masen) has invited companies to prequalify for a contract to develop and operate new onshore wind farms.

    The 400MW Nassim Nord wind power programme includes two wind farms. The first is a 150MW extension to the existing Nassim Koudia Al Baida wind park, located in the Fahs Anjra and Mdiq-Fnideq provinces.

    The second scheme, called Nassim Dar Chaoui wind park, will be located in the provinces of Tangier and Tatouiane. It will have a capacity of approximately 250MW.

    According to an industry source, Masen expects to receive the prequalification submissions on 24 June.

    The project will be implemented under a 30-year power-purchase agreement between Masen and the project company that will include the successful bidder.

    Masen, either alone or with a Moroccan public entity, will take a 35% stake in both the project company and the operation and maintenance (O&M) company that will be formed for the project.

    Masen is expected to issue the request for proposals for the Nassim Nord wind projects in September.

    Owned by Masen and France's EDF Renewables, the Nassim Koudia Al Baida scheme is Morocco's first wind independent prower producer (IPP) project, which had an initial capacity of 50MW. In 2022, additional financing from the  European Bank for Reconstruction and Development (EBRD) and Climate Investment Fund (CTF) aimed to double the plant's capacity, 

    Noor Midelt 2 

    MEED reported on 25 April that Masen has invited prequalified developers and developer consortiums to bid for a contract to develop the second phase of its Noor Midelt solar independent power producer (IPP) programme.

    Located in central Morocco, the Noor Midelt 2 IPP consists of a 400MW solar photovoltaic (PV) power plant with battery storage of two hours.

    The client expects to receive bids for the contract by 8 July.

    2030 target

    Morocco has set a target for 52 per cent of its energy to be produced from clean energy sources by 2030, one of the most ambitious targets in the Middle East and North Africa region.

    Morocco aims to bring its renewable capacity to 10,000MW by 2030. Of the total, solar PV is expected to account for 4,500MW, wind for 4,200MW and hydroelectric for 1,300MW.

    https://image.digitalinsightresearch.in/uploads/NewsArticle/11717256/main.jpg
    Jennifer Aguinaldo
  • Jubail 4 and 6 bidders get more time

    26 April 2024

    Prequalified bidders received a two-month extension for the preparation of proposals for a contract to develop an independent water project (IWP) in Jubail, Saudi Arabia.

    Saudi Water Partnership Company (SWPC) issued the request for proposals (RFP) for the Jubail 4 and 6 IWP in January this year, four months after it qualified nine individual companies and consortiums that can bid for the contract.

    Located in Jubail in Saudi Arabia's eastern province, the plants will be able to treat 600,000 cubic metres a day (cm/d) of seawater using reverse osmosis technology.

    MEED understands the client now expects to receive bids for the contract by 30 June instead of 30 April.

    The following utility developers and investors qualified to bid for the contract: 

    • Abu Dhabi National Energy Company (Taqa)
    • Acciona (Spain)
    • Acwa Power (local)
    • Ajlan & Bros (local) / Rawafid Industrial Company (local)
    • Al-Jomaih Energy Water Company (local)  / Sogex Oman Company (local) 
    • GS Inima (Spain/South Korea)
    • International Power (Engie, France)
    • Marubeni Corporation (Japan)
    • Power & Water Utility Company for Jubail & Yanbu (Marafiq, local)

    Thirty-five companies, including 16 Saudi-based firms, previously expressed interest in the project. 

    The desalination plant will be located 18 kilometres south of Jubail Industrial City, adjacent to four existing desalination units – Jubail phase one, Jubail phase two, and the Jubail 3A and 3B IWP facilities.

    As with the previous seawater reverse osmosis (SWRO) IWP contracts already awarded in the kingdom, the successful bidder, through a project company, will develop the project and sell the entire capacity and output to SWPC under a 25-year water-purchase agreement (WPA).

    A credit support agreement from the government of Saudi Arabia backs SWPC’s obligations under the WPA.

    SWPC’s transaction advisory team for the project comprises Netherlands-headquartered KPMG Professional Services as lead and financial adviser, UK-based Eversheds Sutherland as legal adviser and Canada’s WSP as technical adviser.

    It also appointed UAE-based Future Water & Power Consulting to assist with the project tender and in finalising the site studies required for the bid.

    SWPC has awarded the contracts for six IWP projects in Saudi Arabia – Rabigh 3, Shuqaiq 3, Yanbu 4 (Ar-Rayis 1), Jubail 3A, Jubail 3B and Rabigh 4. A seventh contract for developing the Shuaibah 3 SWRO plan was also directly negotiated and awarded in 2022.

    The seven IWP schemes have a total combined capacity of 3.3 million cm/d.

    Ras Mohaisen

    SWPC recently received two bids for a contract to develop the Ras Mohaisen IWP scheme.

    The bidders are Spain’s Acciona and a team comprising the local firms Acwa Power, Haji Abdullah Alireza & Partners Company and AlKifah Holding.

    The Ras Mohaisen IWP will have the capacity to treat 300,000 cubic metres of seawater a day (cm/d) using reverse osmosis technology.

    It will also include storage tanks with a capacity of 600,000 cubic metres, equivalent to two operating days, and an electrical substation.

     

     

    https://image.digitalinsightresearch.in/uploads/NewsArticle/11716872/main.gif
    Jennifer Aguinaldo
  • Amiral cogen eyes financial close

    26 April 2024

    The developer team for the cogeneration independent steam and power plant (ISPP) serving the Amiral petrochemicals complex in Jubail, Saudi Arabia is expected to reach financial close for the project before the end of the second quarter this year.

    Saudi Aramco Total Refining & Petrochemical Company (Satorp) signed a power and steam purchase agreement with a team that comprises the UAE's Abu Dhabi National Energy Company (Taqa) and Japan's Jera in March. 

    A special purpose entity owned by Taqa (51%) and Jera (49%) will develop the Amiral cogeneration plant on a 25-year build-own-operate basis, extendable by five years on mutual agreement.

    Taqa and Jera will also undertake the plant's operation and maintenance (O&M) through an O&M special purpose entity.

    "The target is to reach financial close by the end of May or June," a source familiar with the project tells MEED. 

    The planned facility is anticipated to have a design capacity of about 475MW of power generation and roughly 452 tonnes an hour of steam from advanced combined-cycle gas-fired technology.

    The firms said the plant is expected to be operational by 2027.

    "The Amiral cogeneration plant will include state-of-the-art power and steam generation systems, gas and water receiving systems, and gas insulated switchgear interconnections while at the same time meeting stringent efficiency standards imposed by the Saudi Energy Efficiency Centre," the firms said on 28 March.

    "The project also has provision for the future installation of a carbon dioxide capture plant and is capable of hydrogen cofiring."

    South Korean contracting company Samsung C&T will undertake the engineering, procurement and construction (EPC) contract for the Amiral cogeneration ISPP project.

    Steam cracker complex

    Integrated with the existing Satorp refinery in Jubail, the new complex aims to house one of the largest mixed-load steam crackers in the Gulf that can produce up to 1,650 kt/y of ethylene and other industrial gases.

    This expansion is expected to attract more than $4bn in additional investment in various industrial sectors, including carbon fibres, lubes, drilling fluids, detergents, food additives, automotive parts and tires. It is also expected to create about 7,000 local direct and indirect jobs.

    Satorp reached the final investment decision on Amiral in December 2022.

    Aramco owns 62.5% of shares in Satorp, while France's TotalEnergies has a 37.5% stake.

    https://image.digitalinsightresearch.in/uploads/NewsArticle/11716656/main.jpg
    Jennifer Aguinaldo
  • Acwa Power signs $356m Barka extension

    25 April 2024

    Barka Water and Power Company (BWPC), a subsidiary of Saudi utility developer Acwa Power, has received a letter of award from Nama Power and Water Procurement Company in Oman (PWP) for extending the power and water purchase agreement (PWPA) for the plant.

    The value of the contract extension is $356m, Acwa Power said in a bourse filing on 25 April.

    The award includes extending the operation of the power plant for eight years and 9 months with operations starting from 1 June 2024, and the water desalination plant for three years starting from 1 September 2024, with an extension option at PWP’s discretion for a further term of three years and another term of two years and nine 9 months for a total of 8 years and 9 months.

    BWPC is registered in Oman and listed in the Muscat Stock Exchange.

    The Barka independent water and power project (IWPP) is located 60 kilometres north of Muscat. It began commercial operations in June 2003, and a majority stake was acquired by Acwa Power in August 2010.

    At the time it started operations, the facility was contributing 6% of the electricity and 24% of the desalinated water in Oman.

    The gas-fired power plant has the capacity to generate 427MW of electricity using combine-cycle gas turbines, while the desalination plant that runs on multi-stage flash technology had an initial capacity of 91,000 cubic metres a day (cm/d).

    A succeeding independent water project entailed the development of a seawater reverse osmosis (SWRO) plant with a capacity of 45,000 cm/d, which became operational in 2014. A further expansion of the SWRO plant, with a capacity of 56,800 cm/d became operational two years later.

    Earlier this week, Acwa Power CEO, Marco Arcelli, said his company is in negotiations with long-term investors, such as pension funds, for the selective sale of assets.

    The report did not specify which assets are being considered for sale.  

    Last week, Arcelli told MEED that Acwa Power and Saudi sovereign wealth vehicle the Public Investment Fund (PIF) are discussing the fourth round of the renewable energy programme that PIF is implementing.

    However, he declined to comment on the outage of one of the company's concentrated solar power plants in Morocco, which is expected to result in $47m of lost revenue for the firm.

    https://image.digitalinsightresearch.in/uploads/NewsArticle/11713505/main.jpg
    Jennifer Aguinaldo